One by one, the officials took their turn to speak. On Tuesday afternoon, during the second week of negotiations at the UN’s annual climate conference, Denmark, Spain, Portugal, and Luxembourg became the latest countries to announce they are working on a fossil fuel phaseout roadmap. Ireland joined a few days later. In doing so, these five joined a small but growing list of countries, including France, Germany, Finland, the Netherlands, and the Pacific countries, that have committed to moving away from oil, gas, and coal.

On the ground in Antalya, these promises were met with a mixed reception. On the one hand, they made it feel like something was actually happening at the annual climate negotiations which otherwise felt flat and empty. For the decade since the landmark Paris Agreement that committed the world to keep climate change within 1.5C degrees of warming, each COP or Conference of the Parties—the annual meeting where signatories of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change come together to negotiate their commitments to doing something about the climate crisis—has been a slow, unrelenting grind, costly in time, treasure, and morale. This time around was no different, with the general mood around the venue averaging out into two words: How’s the vibe? “Cooked.” What’s the situation? “Fucked.” 

If every crisis is an opportunity, there was also a sense that the rolling crises gripping the planet at the moment seemed to offer multiple opportunities for something to happen this year. World leaders are meeting in Antalya amid genocides in Gaza and Sudan and spiraling conflicts initiated by petrostates, from the U.S. to Russia to Israel. Nepal has barely begun to recover from the catastrophic collapse of a glacier that wiped out 10,000 people and a tenth of the country’s GDP in ten minutes. Meanwhile, a monster El Niño is emerging, ready to stomp its way across the planet like Godzilla, tearing through local weather systems along the way. On top of all this, the United Nations Environment Program published a report in September that directly addressed the probability that the world will overshoot the 1.5C goal set by the Paris Climate Agreement, if it has not already. The throughline, of course, is a rich river of oil, gas, and coal, a fifth of which once flowed through the Strait of Hormuz. Where the global public faces surging prices for food and fuel, the fossil fuel industry is reaping record profits. If humanity couldn’t get it together to announce a shift away from this dangerous commodity now, when would it?

And it wasn’t just civil society groups making the connection between reliance on fossil fuels and the cascade of threats facing democracies all over the world at COP31. Danish Minister for Climate, Energy and Utilities, Samira Nawa, gestured to this in announcing her country’s transition roadmap.

“Fossil fuel dependence comes at a high price—for families facing unpredictable energy bills, for countries exposed to geopolitical turmoil, and for our planet,” Nawa said.

On the other hand, there was frustration. The European roadmaps, documents that sought to plot out how each country might end its reliance on fossil fuels, were welcomed in some quarters, but critics across civil society read them as cynical attempts to grab headlines. An analysis by the Fossil Fuel Treaty initiative, an alliance of 30 countries, Indigenous peoples, and civil society groups found many of these plans do not go far enough. Worse, European countries, including some of the same countries that had announced roadmaps, had also turned up to the official COP negotiations in Antalya making it clear that they would be making no new money available for climate finance.

Over the course of two weeks, the hollowness of these processes and halting progress in negotiations caused the pressure to build. Half-way through the second week, Panamanian Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro, intervened to make clear what was at stake.

“We are being held hostage by the petroleum mafia. Not only that, we have all been stricken by Stockholm disease,” he declared. “We love the petroleum guys. We can’t live without them, and they’re so smart that they have convinced us that they are actually doing this for our own good.”

Navarro was met with thunderous applause. Later, he issued an open letter to the presidencies threatening to object to the final decision and hold up the process—set to conclude by end-of-day on Friday the 20th unless it’s delayed, as COP negotiations often are—unless the language of the final text is improved.

To date, work on transitioning away from fossil fuels has largely been done outside the COP process, left to a messy coalition of groups, many with overlapping memberships and interests, all pushing toward the same goal. The Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance bloc of countries, for example, is separate from the Powering Past Coal Alliance bloc, which is separate from the Coalition on Phasing Out Fossil Fuel Subsidies, which is separate from the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative, which is separate to the Santa Marta process. These, in turn, are all working independently of Brazil’s blueprint for the phaseout of fossil fuels, launched last year when the Amazonian nation presided over the annual talks. Civil society now wants each year’s COP president to commit to carrying forward Brazil’s work through Antalya and into Ethiopia, which will host COP32 next year. 

So far the COP31 presidencies of Türkiye and Australia have had other ideas. Both, it is important to remember, oversee economies heavily dependent on fossil fuels and the revenue they generate. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan announced the discovery of two new oil fields in the country on the second day of COP31. Australia is one of the biggest carbon emitters in history, according to an analysis released by Carbon Brief. The country is the second largest exporter of thermal coal and the largest exporter of metallurgical coal, for making steel, while vying with the United States and Qatar for the position as the world’s largest exporter of liquid natural gas.

Among the headline items this year was a call by Türkiye for countries to commit to a global electrification target of 35 percent by 2035. It was a proposal that served as a way to talk about a transition away from fossil fuels without actually talking directly about a transition away from fossil fuels. By Thursday, 90 countries had signed onto the voluntary initiative with the potential for more by the time negotiations close. On the sidelines, civil society groups watched the situation develop and offered tepid support for the initiative, so long as the final version, due at the close of COP31 negotiations, includes protections for Indigenous peoples and language ensuring the electricity was “clean.” The lack of any clear plan to end reliance on fossil fuel, however, meant any new renewable energy capacity could end up adding to existing energy systems instead of replacing costly, inefficient oil, gas, and coal.

That this was the headline initiative, and the negotiations themselves seemed to play second fiddle, is emblematic of a process that was once again lousy with lobbyists and corporate interests. Nearly 100,000 people and 18 billionaires—worth a combined $200 billion and of whom 12 had flown in by private jet, according to a count by Oxfam—descended upon the resort city of Antalya on the coast of the Mediterranean to watch the negotiations play out.

This number included some 14,000 people associated with the Turkish delegation and 103 groups identified by the Kick Big Polluters Out coalition as having a track record of obstructing climate action or working to further fossil fuel interests. Another count by the Fossil Free Politics coalition noted Italy appeared to bring more fossil fuel lobbyists than ministers to the negotiations: 50 fossil fuel reps for its one environment minister. France once again brought TotalEnergies CEO Patrick Pouyanné to Antalya and 16 other fossil fuel lobbyists, which was, in fairness, a lower number than in previous years. Belgium, for its part, brought five.

For the better part of two weeks, there hasn’t been much to watch—Australia, in its capacity as COP Co-President for Negotiations, has said it wants to run a calm, orderly, transparent and boring process that would be familiar to observers of Australian statecraft. The heavy focus at COP31 on “getting on with the job” and not talking directly about fossil fuels, is a deliberate Australian communications strategy intended to barrel through the fraught politics of climate change. Though it has been moderately successful domestically, it is not a strategy that appears to have mapped well to international forums. Even as the final hours approach, dozens of key issues remain in play.

By far the two overarching issues have been those that have always been a source of pain during the COP process: finance and the fate of fossil fuels. Developing countries continue to argue that if rich countries want poor countries to move faster and leapfrog dirty, polluting fossil fuel infrastructure, it all needs to be paid for. Under the polluter pays principle, that money should come from countries responsible for driving the climate crisis. So far, the European countries in particular—including those that have released fossil fuel roadmaps—have been studiously silent.

Developed countries in general haven’t been in a giving mood of late, especially with demagogic right-wing parties waiting in the wings, ready to seize on large cash transfers to foreigners for domestic political advantage. Going into COP31, the EU’s climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra told Bloomberg the bloc would be offering no new money during the negotiations, describing any demands for such funding as “dead in the water” and effectively ending the conversation before it began. Developing countries, meanwhile, have not been willing to bend on what they see as basic questions of justice. In the closing hours of the negotiations, the Climate Action Network (CAN) called a press conference to denounce the European Union as obstructionist, and damn COP31 as “the worst COP ever.”

The Climate Action Network is holding a press conference damming COP31 as "the worst ever".Tasneem Essop from Climate Action Network International: “What we are leaving this COP with is the interests of corporates and the destruction of people.”

— Royce Kurmelovs (@roycerk2.bsky.social) 2026-11-20T08:38:44.134Z

“When you come into a COP and a commissioner of a very important regional bloc says we are not coming with any finance, finance is ‘dead in the water’—think about that,” Tasneem Essop, CAN executive director said. “For us in the Global South, dead in the water is very literal. So it’s a shameful way to come to a COP where we are going to be fighting for adaptation finance to protect people from being dead in the water.”

In contrast to the trillions needed for adaptation, the total money pledged to adaptation finance at COP31 amounted to $50 million, Tasneem said, which is half the cost of an F-35 Lightning fighter jet.

“We’re not even going to measure that $50 million in relation to the $3 trillion that rich nations are spending on wars, a genocide, and conflicts across the world,” Essop added.

No one, however, wants countries to walk away from the negotiations. Multilateralism cannot be allowed to fail, they say. As the final hours approach, what they want is for parties to stay and fight for a better outcome.

The consistent messaging from Australia, meanwhile, both in its public statements and private briefings to select media, has been that it is seeking “the most ambitious decision consensus will allow” and that it sees its role overseeing negotiations as something like an umpire at a football match. That ambition, however, has run up against agitation by a bullish Saudi Arabia and other parties. Drafts of a possible deal on offer in the final hours stripped out any mention of fossil fuels, direct discussion of a “transition away from fossil fuels” and emphasised heavy reliance on speculative carbon, capture and storage technologies.

These dynamics have spilled over into related processes, such as the upcoming report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. The IPCC’s reports underpin climate negotiations by providing a comprehensive review of the available climate science. And they have influence far beyond the negotiations, too. Stock markets can rise or fall on the place of a comma or the order of a sentence within the global agreements these documents inform.

A number of countries from the Global South and the European Union want the next report published in time for next year’s COP32 in Ethiopia where the world will check its work to date and set new targets. This is known as the “Global Stocktake,” an accounting exercise where governments measure real world progress on emissions reduction against what countries had agreed to do to limit climate change to 1.5C. Should real world results fall short of the mark, new targets will have to be set to maintain the binding commitment. A bloc composed of Russia, India, China, Saudi Arabia, and Kenya is seeking to stop the push to release the next IPCC report in time to inform the Global Stocktake, and delay publication until sometime beyond November 2028. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India have also held up passing the budget for the organization. They claim releasing the report next year would deny scientists from developing countries the opportunity to contribute.

Speaking to Drilled anonymously as they could not speak on behalf of the IPCC, scientists working on the report described the pushback as a cynical, bad faith attack on the process that has little to do with their personal welfare. Rather, dragging out the timelines makes their work harder and disadvantages developing world contributors more, they said. The future IPCC report is expected to produce numbers showing the world has not done enough, which should result in efforts to do more. Delaying the publication of this report until 2028 or 2029 won’t produce better science, they say, but will mean the world cannot act on these numbers until sometime in 2033, the next opportunity governments have to assess their progress and adjust their targets accordingly.

Whatever the decision in the closing hours of negotiations at COP31, or about the publication schedule of the next IPCC report, one thing is true: the only commodity more precious than petroleum right now is time.


When it’s delivered to your inbox, this newsletter also includes highlights from the latest podcast episode and a curated list of climate must-reads (and listens and watches). It never takes more than 10 minutes to read and people tell us it helps them keep on top of everything happening on climate. Subscribe below!

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Original reporting and analysis, plus our five climate must-reads (or watches or listens) delivered to your inbox

Royce Kurmelovs is an investigative journalist in Australia. In addition to contributing to The Guardian, The Saturday Paper, Rolling Stone and several other outlets, he is the author of several books,...