One in eight people globally—around 1 billion people— and 3 million people in Mexico alone could be displaced by climate change by 2050. Lessons learned from a rushed resettlement underscore what governments owe to climate-displaced communities, not only after homes wash away, but also long before.
Read transcript
AMY: By 2050, as many as 1 in 8 people around the world could be displaced by sea level rise, drought, wildfires, extreme heat and other climate disasters.
Nina Lakhani has been reporting on communities on the frontlines of the climate crisis for the past decade. Earlier this year she visited some of the hardest hit places in Latin America, to see how local communities are responding.
I’m Amy Westervelt, and this is Drilled. Nina’s here to bring you stories from three countries. This week we’re in Mexico.
[El Bosque ambi up]
On a hot sticky day in May, I visited what’s left of El Bosque, a small coastal community in the Mexican state of Tabasco. I’m a climate justice reporter, and I’d come to see what rising sea level has done to this fishing village. I walked along the coastline with Don Nereo Martinez. He was a fisherman in El Bosque for almost four decades, he’s 76 now.
Nereo: Aquí, esto de aquí era puro manglar grandísimo, buuu, grandísimo. Aquí había monos, había mapaches, había cuanta cosa aquí. Sí, pero se metió el este que nos sacó a nosotros y mira lo que le hizo.(Nereo 1 arriving)
This was a huge mangrove forest, he tells me. There were monkeys, raccoons, all sorts of wildlife. Until the sea took everything. He hasn’t been back here in over two years.
Nina: Mira ahora estamos en la playa, al lado del mar. Sí. Y enfrente de nosotros está una, una casita media tirada. [Nereo 2 0.15]
He shows me a washed up concrete little bathroom wedged in the sand, on what’s left of the beach.
Nereo: Ese es un baño.
Nina: Ese es un baño, sí. De un restaurante?
Nereo: No, de una casa.
He points out several more bathrooms and water cisterns. They are all that remain of entire streets swallowed up by the sea.
[music]
I’ve visited communities devastated by climate change all across the Americas, and looking out at the remains of this town, a familiar sense of dread comes over me.
Nina: Y, y su casa? [Nereo 1 8.35]
Nereo: No, mi casa está por allá.
Nina: ¿Podemos ir caminando?
Nereo: Sí, sí podemos ir.
He tells me we can walk over to his old house.
We step over fallen trees, jagged concrete slabs, a wardrobe, empty beer bottles and some shirts and a baseball cap. I wonder who this stuff belongs to. There’s a canoe perfectly buried in the sand, next to fishing nets and a thread bare hammock tied to a dead tree trunk. This is a total mess.
There’s not much beach to walk on, and it wasn’t easy navigating over what’s left of the vegetation and people’s lives.
Nina: ¡Uyyy! Nos vamos a mojar (Nereo 3 4.33)
Don Nereo offered out his hand.
Nereo: Cuidado con el palo (5.46).
Nina: Si, si.
We arrive at his house. He tears up as soon as we get there.
Nereo: Ahí está mi casita, mire. No, hombre. Dios padre. SOBBING [Nereo 3 26.40]
It’s his first time back since the rising sea forced him to abandon home. The floor is covered with rubble, furniture and all kinds of trash, washed in by the waves. I struggle to find space to walk. I’m finding it hard to imagine Don Nereo raising his family here. It all just looks so broken.
Nereo: [asking for answers from God] Dios mío, ¿por qué hiciste esta cosa, padre? Me dejaste en una ruina tan grande, Señor. ¿Por qué lo hiciste, Padre?
[fade tape down after this and continue his crying under the next paragraph of narration]
Don Nereo is a religious man. And like a lot of people I’ve met reporting on climate injustice over the past decade, he’s looking to his God for answers. Ifeel desperately sad watching this elderly man weep for all that he’s lost. But it’s not just sadness, I also feel angry when I meet communities devastated by the climate crisis, furious in fact.
We know that greenhouse gases released from burning oil, gas and coal are making the planet hotter, melting ice sheets and glaciers that flow into our oceans. The oceans are also expanding due to warmer waters, which we also know will make the sea level rise further, destroying more homes and lives.
As we walk along the shore Don Nereo tells me how he believes the bible explains what’s happening to El Bosque. He recites some scripture and mentions angels. But for me the explanation is us, it’s our government’s refusal to take action…
[theme music]
Welcome to Displaced, our series from communities on the front lines of climate breakdown, and the race against time to save them.
I’m Nina Lakhani, a global climate justice reporter for Drilled.
I’ve spent the past few months reporting from places where climate displacement is already happening, to see what this looks like and feels like close up. I met people who are fighting to hold on to their land, and others who are starting over.
This story often gets told as one of North versus South, but communities in fossil fuel producing countries in Latin America are also on the front lines of the crisis.
In this episode we’re visiting the first and only community recognised by the Mexican government as climate displaced. In 2023 Mexico’s president promised to relocate residents of El Bosque, this small fishing community in the state of Tabasco. I went to see how the big move went.
Act 1
[ambi up]
El Bosque was founded in the early 1980s by landless people from the neighbouring state of Veracruz, who saw an opportunity to lift their families out of poverty. Back then there was an abundance of fish and this narrow peninsula was covered in mangroves and thick vegetation – hence the name El Bosque, which means the forest.
But there was a threat lurking offshore. By the mid-2010s, storms started to hit harder, and huge waves swept away a few sturdy old trees, then the odd house. Fishermen had to go further out to sea to catch enough fish, but they were unaware that climate change and oil industry pollution were starting to affect fish stocks. The community had no idea how bad things would get.
[music cue]
Lilia Gama is a geologist and climate scientist at the Juárez Autonomous University of Tabasco. She studies sea level rise and coastal erosion across the Gulf of Mexico, including here in the state of Tabasco. We drove along the coast together to see the damage.
Lilia: estamos en una parte en donde vemos que la carretera empieza a acercarse al, al mar, aunque es realmente el mar que se está acercando a la carretera,
She points out the spots where the sea is getting dangerously close to the road. One section is unpassable, and we turn back.
She tells me that El Bosque was one of the places that worried her most. In 2022 she went to talk with the residents. By then, she says, it was clear to her the people would have to leave.
Lillia Gama: Bueno, la comunidad del Bosque vivía en la desembocadura del Usumacinta, en el flanco que da hacia el mar y por la parte de atrás, digámoslo así, de la comunidad, pues estaba la desembocadura del río. Entonces, lo que ahí sucedió es que igual por una serie de procesos, eh, erosivos, la playa se empezó a perder y a acercarse la línea de costa a la comunidad y como del otro lado tienen el río, pues no tenían forma de, eh, reubicarse más atrás, ¿no? [Lilia Gama 2]
Lilia says the community of El Bosque was built in between the Usumacinta River on one side, and the sea on the other. As the beach disappeared due to erosion and rising sea level, the coastline crept closer and closer to people’s homes, leaving them trapped between the river and the sea with nowhere to go.
Lupe Cobos was a crab fisher and community spokesperson in El Bosque who met with Lilia during that visit.
Lupe [12.42]: Cuando ella llega y ella se baja de su camioneta, lo primerito que hice fue preguntar: “Doctora, dígame que el bosque se va a salvar”.
Y ella así co– ya ve que ella es muy… Tiene una mirada, un… Hasta para darte una mala noticia es muy dulce. Me dijo así como con esa risa que tiene, pero como…
Yo vi que en sus ojos me dijo: “No”, me dijo: “No, el bosque está irremediablemente ya roto.
Lupe Actor: When she arrived and stepped out of her truck, the very first thing I did was ask: “Doctor, tell me El Bosque is going to be saved.” And you know how she is, even when she’s breaking bad news to you, she’s so sweet. She responded with that sweet laugh of hers, but I could see in her eyes she meant , “No,” she said, “No, El Bosque is already irreparably broken.”
By Lillia Gama’s visit in 2022, much of El Bosque’s beach was gone and the seafront houses were underwater. The school and kindergarten one block inland, were flooded and no longer usable. She explained to residents that the coastal erosion was now unstoppable.
El Bosque has disappeared faster than the climate models predicted. Lilia told me that in the next decade or so, the river and the sea will probably join together and leave behind only a few small sandy islands. This would most likely have happened eventually due to the natural dynamics of the water, but climate change has turbocharged the process.
Lilia’s visit left Lupe and the rest of the community with no doubt. It was a matter of when El Bosque would end up under water, not if.
Lupe [14.06]: Nosotros sabíamos que el mar se nos venía, pero no sabíamos qué nos estaba pasando. Hasta que llegaron a compartirnos de esa experiencia y de esa sabiduría. Entonces El Bosque entendió que el Bosque se le estaba acabando el tiempo.
Lupe Actor: We knew that the sea was coming, but we did not know what was happening to us. Until they came to share that experience and that knowledge with us. Then we understood that El Bosque was running out of time.
If we don’t transition away from fossil fuels fast, some models suggest that sea level rise and floods could leave up to half the entire state of Tabasco uninhabitable by the end of the century.
[music change]
A few months after climate scientist Lilia Gama’s visit to El Bosque in 2022, the then president of Mexico promised that the federal government would relocate the community. To many residents, that felt like a huge relief.
[Archive tape from the morning press conference]
That’s former president Andres Manuel López Obrador, known as Amlo, who’s from the same state, Tabasco. He’s responding to a journalist in February 2023 who asked how the government would help the community, because El Bosque was disappearing due to climate change. Amlo instructs his infrastructure minister to go meet with the community that very same day.
I remember that for me as a reporter, this felt like a big moment for the entire climate justice movement. Mexico has laws that recognise climate change as a problem. The State doesn’t deny it. But Mexico is also the fourth largest oil producer in the Americas, after the US, Canada and Brazil. Its state oil company, Pemex, is part of the national identity.
And Tabasco is one of Mexico’s biggest oil producing states. During Amlo’s 6 years in power, Mexico’s transition to renewable energy sources went backwards. So for his government to recognise a community as climate-displaced – and accept the government’s duty to relocate them – was a huge deal. It showed that community organising and climate litigation could force governments to do the right thing.
[music]
In November 2024, 51 families moved into purpose-built houses in a new neighbourhood called Nuevo Bosque, or New Forest.
Nuevo Bosque is about 8 miles, that’s 12 KM, inland on the outskirts of a small city called Frontera. The community wanted to be rehoused closer to the sea so they could keep fishing, but the government said no. This is because climate models show that any closer to the coast and they’d likely be flooded out again within a few years. Here, the authorities told them, they should be safe for 30 years. The media flocked to Nuevo Bosque, which was declared a success story. It was ‘case closed’ for the government.
[music cue/transition]
But back in El Bosque, I got the sense that the relocation wasn’t all good news.
[ambi up]
On the beach Don Nereo points out more buildings that the sea tore down.
Nina: mira, si usted echa un vistazo por allá sobre la orilla del mar.. cuéntanos qué estamos viendo. [Nereo2 1.23 ]
Nereo: Pues aquí estamos viendo… Pues todo lo que acabó el mar, todo lo que desbarató, todos los pedazos de casa, los pedazos de jilberes que quedaron. //
Nereo: Entonces, nos acabó con todo.
He shows me water storage tanks poking through as the tide goes out. The first house the sea swept away, back in 2019, he tells me, belonged to fisherman Pablo Cardoza. Yet no-one seems to know why Pablo and dozens of other residents were left out of the relocation scheme, and not given a house in Nuevo Bosque.
Nereo: La casa de Pablo Cardoza está ahí, todo eso. Está tan lejos. Ha botado todo eso… nomás quedó el nombre… Voy a reubicarme bien aquí, como los palos no están iguales. [Nereo3]
Don Nereo has a hard time finding the location of Pablo’s old house, the trees he used to orient/e himself with are now underwater.
No, pues no se ve, pero no, miento, están aquí está la casa. Ahí está la de su abuela y aquí está la de – de – la cooperativa.
For a minute he gets confused and points out the wrong house. I’m disorientated without the trees, he tells me.
// Entonces Pablo vivía de aquel ladito. [cut down Nereo3 0.48]
Nina: usted antes se ubicaba por los palos? [Nereo 3.31]
Nereo: Pues ya perdón, no hay.
Nina: ¿Entonces se siente un poco desubicado?
Nereo: Pues estoy desorientado.
We keep walking along the shoreline to the old primary school and kindergarten. It was the beating heart of El Bosque, according to literally everyone I met. After classes were done, the kids would play for hours on the beach, and those who didn’t get on too well with school always had fishing to fall back on.
[Back to walking along the coast]
Nereo: Este es el baño de la escuela, mire. El baño de la escuela. Ahí va. Ahí arriba tenía dos tanques. [Nereo 3 21.23]
Don Nereo and I stand looking at the remnants of the old school.
Bits of wood and trash have lodged the kindergarten’s bathroom into the shoreline at a 45 degree angle. On the side wall, there’s a freshly painted angry looking orange fish smoking what looks like a spliff. Waves flow in and out of what was a classroom. I notice a bunch of tiny sandals where the kindergarten used to be.
Nina: Mira, todavía hay chancles (Nereo 3 14.26)
Nereo: De todo.
Nina: Hay pertenencias, ¿no?
Nereo: Sí, todo hay, pero ya, ¿no?
Don Nereo tells me that it hurts his heart seeing the things left behind here. His children and grandchildren, and great grandchildren, studied at this school.
Ya estoy triste del corazón.
Nina: Y aquí, aquí en la escuela, sus hijos aquí estudiaban, sí ¿Y cómo se siente al ver la escuela así? (Nereo 3 18.28)
Nereo: Ay, Dios mío, pa qué le cuento. ¿Cómo me voy a sentir? Con ganas de tirarme de cabeza ahí pa ver si ya hasta ahí ya no veo nada, //
Nina: [hard to hear but talking about the tiled floor that’s still there] puro mosaico. [Nereo 3 19.19]
I notice the pretty tiled flooring.
Nereo: Sí, no, estas escuelas estaban bien hechas. Eran dos escuelas. Sí, dos, dos aulas. Dos escuelas y el, y el kindercito.
This school was well-built, he says.
As we continue walking, Don Nereo stops every time he spots a fish in the waves.
Nereo: Mira, mira cómo hay pescado, ve. Eso es lo que me da tristeza ver eso. [Nereo 1 2.18]
Nina: A ver al pescado.
Nereo: Sí, pues qué, porque yo aquí, estando aquí yo en el bosque, aquí agarro, amarro de ese palo el cabo en la orillita y me aviento a pie. Mmm, me aviento a pie y allá adelante le pongo un madericito y un grampín. Y ahí en la noche pasa- ¿Como una red? Ahí las redes, sí. Ahí en la noche pasa el róbalo, pasa el chucumite, pasa la liceta, pasa la trucha, pasa el ronco blanco
He tells me how he’d just walk into the sea with a line and a hook, and catch loads of different fish.
Nereo: y todo eso es dinero.
Nina: y entonces a ver los peces brincando.
Nereo: Pues me da tristeza, me siento mal. Es más que la verdad me dan ganas de, pues de planamente de llorar, ver esta desgracia que nosotros estábamos. Mira!
Seeing the fish jump above the waves makes him want to cry. He tells me about coming here with his grandson Andrés. He really misses fishing, and can’t help but smile when he talks about the old days.
Nereo: Entonces yo al ver aquí pescábamos yo y mi nieto Andrés, aquí, aquí todo esto, en el cayuco. [3.27]
He tells me it’s not that people were rich in El Bosque, but no-one went hungry. There was always plenty of fish to eat and the women made money working together to make piles of corn tortillas to sell to fishermen.
Nereo: Mi vieja echaba las tortillas y mis hijas las volteaban y le hacían dos, tres masecas, pura tortilla pa comer y coco. [Nereo1 12.59]
But when they moved to Nuevo Bosque, they soon realised their new life would be very different.
MIDROLL
[Nuevo Bosque ambi up]
Nuevo Bosque consists of four streets of identical single storey homes painted white with a peachy orange trim around the roof and windows. Each house has just two bedrooms, and a small front and back yard.There’s a playground, a basketball court and some benches, next to huge concrete letters painted white that spell out “Nuevo Bosque”. This is the New Forest community, where everything is different.
We sat out front of Don Nereo’s new home, with his wife Doña Lucia and daughter Anahi who lives next door with her family. There’s a drum of heavy machinery from the construction site next to Nuevo Bosque where the government is building hundreds of new apartments. There’s an occasional sea breeze, but it was so humid that my t-shirt stuck to my back. Even my eyebrows were sweaty. The new buildings will block the breeze and turn Nuevo Bosque into an urban heat island.
Don Nereo doesn’t fish any more. The bus to the coast stopped after the sea damaged the road and the taxi fare is unaffordable on his state pension. He can’t find a job, and he and Doña Lucia are struggling to make ends meet.
As he sits in his folding chair, Don Nereo reminisces about how he used to be able to buy any food that his wife craved.
Nereo: Si es que teníamos una, ahora sí que teníamos una felicidad como que si hubiéramos tenido cinco millones de pesos en la casa. No, no, no, si no, si no me preocupaba yo por nada. Yo a ella le compraba esto, lo otro, lo que ella me pedía. A veces venía yo al centro y: “Oye, viejo, tráeme esto”. “Sí, mamita, yo te lo traigo”. “Tráeme manzanas, tráeme esto”. “Sí, yo te lo traigo”. Y yo le traía contenta (Nereo house2 9.53)
Nina: Y ahora cuando, cuando quiere comprar algo?
Nereo: No, tengo que pensar cómo hacerle. Porque le vamos quitando por cachitos al dinero que nos dan
I never worried about anything, he tells me. I could afford to buy her apples, or whatever food she wanted. It felt like we were millionaires, he says. His daughter Anahi chimes in, she says she notices her parents have lost weight.
[[Anahi 19.56: Pues yo veo porque ellos ahora están más delgados. // Pues yo siento que la comida aquí en Frontera es menos saludable, porque allá en El Bosque, pues todos sabemos que el pescado es muy saludable- Ya. Tiene muchos nutrientes. Ya. Y yo siento que como ellos tenían la dieta casi la mayoría del tiempo era pescado en diferente forma. También consumía mucha jaiba. Claro que yo siento que tenían más nutrientes. Y aquí no, porque aquí ahora sí que tiene que ser todo, todo comprado. (Nereo house2)]]]
She remembers how they used to mostly eat fresh fish. Now all their food has to be bought. It’s a much less healthy lifestyle.
When they lived in El Bosque, the family also had ducks and chickens, as well as a vegetable garden and coconut and tamarind trees.
Don Nereo says that here, no one wants to hire an old man like him. And anyway he doesn’t like to leave doña Lucia alone for too long. Lucia left El Bosque months before her husband. The sound of the waves crashing into the house gave her nightmares and the constant evacuations made her blood pressure and diabetes levels spin out of control.
Nina: Y señora, ¿usted qué le, qué le hace falta de la vida del Bosque? (Nereo house2)
Lucia: Pues comía un pescadito y, este, hacíamos caldo, freíamos, hacíamos ceviche, todo eso. Y eso, pues de hecho uno menos.
When I ask her what she misses about their old life, she talks about the meals they’d enjoy together – fish soup, ceviche, fried fish.
Nina: Y usted, u-usted se siente triste, o sea, am, s-s– como porque se ve un poco triste usted, se ve tris– usted, se ve tris– se siente…
Lucia: Sí, porque, pues no me ingrí yo aquí, hasta pena ahorita que me estoy ingriendo, pero no me ingrí.
I don’t feel right here, she says. I am trying to fit in but I don’t feel right.
[music cue]
Nuevo Bosque was inaugurated without running water or a school. The kids were split up and enrolled in schools around the city, called Frontera, but some found the adjustment really hard. So the parents got together and brought in an old trailer which is parked on the edge of Nuevo Bosque.
Nina teaching English to the school kids
When I visit the narrow laminate trailer that now serves as Nuevo Bosque’s primary school, the teacher has me give her excited little students a quick English lesson. There’s a row of plastic desks and chairs facing the wall and Flora, a little girl with a huge grin, shows me her reading certificate. It feels like a stretch to call this a classroom; there is no bathroom or running water so if a kid needs the toilet, they have to run home. There was a storm the previous night and the day began with a couple of the kids helping the teacher, Isabel, to sweep out the rain water from the floor of the trailer. It’s like an oven. Isabel told me that the heat makes the kids sleepy and irritable. Some get headaches, and find it hard to focus. By 8.30am it was already too hot for me.
This laminate oven is an interim solution until the community can find some land on which the education department has promised to build a proper classroom.
Isabel the teacher tells me that a community without a school isn’t a proper community. And these kids have missed so much of their education already. First it was the pandemic, we all remember how hard that was for kids everywhere. But a few months after in person classes restarted, in late 2020, the sea flooded the school in El Bosque. Isabel still gave classes when and where she could, sometimes under a palm tree or an abandoned house, but the kids fell behind. Don Nereo tells me his 11-year-old great grandson can barely read or write.
In 2022, after the scientist Lilia Gama assessed the situation in El Bosque, a law firm filed an administrative complaint on behalf of the community. The firm’s called Nuestro Futuro, or Our Future, and specialises in Environmental Justice. They’re based in Mexico City.
The complaint generated loads of media attention and El Bosque became an emblematic climate displacement case – cited by the UN and other international bodies. All of this pressure is what led to the Mexican president acknowledging the government’s duty to relocate the community.
[music cue]
After my visit to El Bosque, I went to meet Nora Cabrera, the founder of Nuestro Futuro. It was the morning after the Mexico-Czechia world cup game. We caught up on the goals before I told her what my reporting had found.
Nora: Qué gusto conocerte en persona.n
Nina: Sí, igualmente.
Nora: ¿Cómo estás?
Nina: Media cruda por el partido.
Nora: Pero oye, ¿qué tal? Estuvo increíble, ¿verdad?
Nora actor: It’s nice to meet you in person
Nina: Same
Nora actor: How are you?
Nina: A bit hungover because of the game
Nora actor: But hey, It was amazing, wasn’t it?
Nora acknowledges that the relocation of El Bosque was not good enough. It was unjust, she tells me.
Nora (21:00): Y a mí lo que me parece que es como algo bien preocupante de lo que está pasando con la post reubicación de la comunidad del Bosque, es que si la comunidad no logra poder estar en un nuevo territorio que lo habiten como propio, es una reubicación fallida.
Nora actor: And what seems really worrying to me about what’s happening after the relocation of the El Bosque community is that if the community can’t manage to be in a new place and inhabit it as their own, then it’s a failed relocation.
She says the move, no matter how well intentioned, was poorly planned and many residents have seen a decline in living standards.
Nora Cabrera (23.19): Tú los viste. O sea, tú no estás viendo a una comunidad vulnerable, estás viendo a una comunidad vulnerabilizada por el sistema. Pero la comunidad, las personas de la comunidad son personas que le han resistido a todo, que vienen de una migración de Veracruz batallando muchísimo, que salieron adelante, que sus hijos ya fueron a la universidad, muchos de ellos, y que ahora los hijos de esos hijos ya no pueden ir a la primaria porque no hay condiciones para ir a la primaria. Entonces, ese nivel de regresión habla del proceso de la injusticia climática.
Nora Actor: You saw them. I mean, you aren’t looking at a vulnerable community; you are looking at a community made vulnerable by the system. And still the community—the people within it—are individuals who’ve withstood everything; they’re people who migrated from Veracruz after a tremendous struggle, who succeeded and saw many of their children go to university, but whose grandchildren now can’t even attend primary school because the conditions for doing so simply do not exist. // So, that level of regression speaks to the process of climate injustice.
Nora (41.07): El Bosque nos enseñó que cuando el cambio climático llega a un territorio, se afectan todos los derechos humanos.
Nora Actor: El Bosque taught us that when climate change reaches a territory, all human rights are affected.
[music cue]
The fact the government recognised El Bosque as climate displaced, and that most residents were rehoused, was a big step. People were genuinely relieved to be safe from the rising sea.
Being close to the city means the hospital is nearby and there’s good internet and phone service. The teenagers love this, of course. But, most people are more isolated and less active than they were in El Bosque, as everyone, children and adults, now spend a lot more time indoors. Like with most city living, fast food is a lot easier to find in Nuevo Bosque, Money is tighter, and for the first time mothers don’t always know where the next meal for their kids is coming from.
But the thing is, fishing wasn’t just a job for the people of El Bosque, it was a core part of who they were – both as individuals and a community. Don’t get me wrong, they are grateful for the new houses, but being cut off from the sea has been devastating in so many ways. It has deeply impacted their sense of self worth and identity.
This sense of loss is a part of climate displacement that we need to be thinking about and planning for now, as millions of communities all over the world are at risk of losing their homes. Because starting over is not just about providing new houses. We need to start planning for resettling communities, not just relocation.
[music cue]
I asked Lupe Cobos, the crab fisher and community spokesperson, about the division of labour between men and women in El Bosque’s fishing industry.
Lupe [4.31]:
Nina: El trabajo entre hombres y mujeres en el bosque?
Lupe: Era mutuo. // Los varones se iban a pescar y las mujeres esperábamos en casa, pero también en la orilla del río, a esperar cuando el pescador llega, pues ellas hacen la labor de una palabra que es media… que digo no existe ni en el diccionario, que ya la he buscado. Esa, esa actividad que le llamamos nosotros así de relajo, como garrulear
Lupe actor: The work was shared between men and women. The men would go fishing, and we women would wait down by the riverbank for the fisherman’s return, because we performed a task known by a word that is… well, a word that doesn’t even exist in the dictionary; I’ve looked for it. It’s that activity we casually refer to as *garruliar*.
She says it means helping the fishermen- taking the fish off the boat, packing them into crates, and weighing them. In exchange the women would receive fish to feed their family – or to sell for some extra income.
Lupe: Si tú le preguntas a la comunidad qué son, ellas no te van a decir que son amas de casa. No sé, algunas dos que te digan eso. La mayoría va a decir: “Soy pescadora”. //yo me considero gente de mar y yo sin el mar No soy nadie.
Lupe actor: If you ask the women what they are, they won’t tell you they’re housewives—well, maybe one or two might say that. The majority will say, “I’m a fisherwoman.” I consider myself a person of the sea, and without the sea, I’m nobody.
[beat/music]
I spent a night with some of the women from Nuevo Bosque who still make the eight mile trek back to their old home to help the fishermen. They did make a bit of money but I got the sense that for most it was more about being together and enjoying the sounds of the waves and the sea breeze. The hours flew by as the women swung in hammocks, talked about the old days, and told jokes, lots of dirty jokes.
Fishing was front and centre of men and women’s identity, and losing this has been devastating – it feels to me like people are still grieving.
Nora Cabrera, the lawyer with Nuestro Futuro, says she also worries about the mental health of the residents from El Bosque.
Nora (13.41): O sea, como ese desamparo de las autoridades que se sentía cuando el mar estaba comiendo sus casas y que no sabían qué seguía y qué iba a pasar con el siguiente temporal.
Nora actor: I mean, it’s like that sense of abandonment by the authorities—the feeling when the sea was eating away at their homes and they didn’t know what would come next or what would happen when the next storm hit.
Before journalism I was a mental health nurse and in Nuevo Bosque, I recognized signs of depression and anxiety in lots of residents. Nora tells me she’s worried about what comes next for them.
Nora: Ahora, con un desamparo así, en donde no se, no se mira a las personas en términos de las necesidades reales que tiene una comunidad que la migran de una zona rural, porque el, el, la costa es una zona rural, a una zona urbana, a una periferia de una zona urbana y la siguen urbanizando.
Nora actor: Now, with abandonment like this, where I don’t know, people are not looked at in terms of the real needs that a community has that migrates from a rural area, because the, the, the coast is a rural area, to the edge of an urban area, that’s getting even more urban…
Backstory Scene 11; THE POLITICAL CASE GOING FORWARD
The El Bosque relocation generated political momentum. In late 2025, Mexico submitted its latest NDC, which stands for “Nationally Determined Contribution”. This is the climate action plan countries which have signed the Paris Climate Agreement are required to submit to the UN every five years. For the first time, the country acknowledged that climate change is causing irreversible harm, which in the UN climate world is technically known as “loss and damage.” Mexico also now accepts that this will require reparations for some communities.
And Nora says the El Bosque case is far from closed.
Nora (14.31): Es un desamparo muy preocupante porque es no entender la problemática del desplazamiento. Es así, como otra vez la injusticia.
Nora actor: It is a deeply worrying kind of abandonment, because it stems from a failure to understand the issue of displacement. It’s just… injustice, all over again.
[beat]
From a climate justice perspective, there are two big ways to think about loss and damage. At the international level, wealthydeveloped countries that have contributed most to climate change like the US, Canada, the UK, Germany, and the Netherlands are under legaland societal pressure to make reparations to poorer states that have contributed the least but are suffering the most.
Mexico is one of the few countries that is both a top oil producerand highly vulnerable to climate change. It is currently the 11th largest oil producer in the world, and among the top 20 biggest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions historically. It could one day end up facing loss and damage claims from other states.
But more likely first the government will face lawsuits for failing to protect its own people from foreseeable harms caused by climate change.
Nora [1.06.]: Hoy parece que es muy claro que, por ejemplo, el caso El Bosque es un caso de pérdidas y daños, porque no se generaron condiciones nunca de adaptación o de que fuera realmente una reubicación planificada para poder hablar de que eso constituye una política de adaptación.
Nora: Pero no todos los casos de desplazamiento tienen que ser pérdidas y daños.
Nina: Y ojalá que no sean.
Nora: Y ojalá que no sean.
Nora actor: Today, it seems quite clear that the El Bosque case is a case of loss and damage, because conditions for adaptation—or for what could truly be called a planned relocation—were never created, so one can’t say it‘s an adaptation policy. But not all cases of displacement have to be loss and damage.
Nina in studio: And let’s hope they aren’t.
Nora actor: And let’s hope they aren’t.
[beat]
Mexico, like many other countries, still has no climate adaptation plan that sets out how it will protect and prepare communities from climate breakdown. Nora argues that the government could therefore be liable under domestic law to make reparations for “loss and damage,” that’s those irreversible climate impacts.
Last year the highest court in the world, the International Court of Justice, ruled that all states have a duty to take climate action to prevent foreseeable harms. This includes transitioning away from fossil fuels as quickly as possible, regulating polluting corporations, and implementing good climate adaptation measures.
This is why all over the world, lawyers like Nora Cabrera are taking governments to court to force them to stop with the delays, and do the right thing.
Nora (1.01.42): Entonces jurídicamente tienes un camino para vincular la falta de política de adaptación a una omisión del Estado mexicano, indistintamente de su, de su carácter global en términos de emisor.
Nora actor: So, from a legal standpoint, you have a way to link the lack of an adaptation policy—to an omission on the part of the Mexican State, regardless of its global status as a polluter.
One recent study predicts that 3 million people in Mexico will be displaced by climate change in the next 25 years. Where will they all go? Mexico needs to prepare now for planned resettlements, because the longer it takes to get good policies in place, the more expensive, the more unjust and the more unsustainable the moves will be.
Nora worries that without good planning, people displaced by climate change could overwhelm places like Mexico City and Guadalajara where extreme heat and water shortages are already getting worse
In July this year, Nora’s law firm filed a lawsuit on behalf of 7 of the people from El Bosque who were inexplicably left out of the relocation. The lawyers hope it ends up in the Mexican supreme court. A ruling there could set a precedent for obligations the state has to other climate displaced communities in the future.
The current Mexican government is aware – and worried – about the pending surge in climate displacement. And even though the oil rigs keep pumping here, energy transition plans are slowly picking up. The long promised climate displacement and adaptation policies that should make leaving home less traumatic for the next El Bosque, and the one after that, are coming.
[music cue]
Nereo: Sí, sí, yo sigo con el sueño.
Don Nereo tells me he still dreams of being able to return to fish at El Bosque.
Nina: Entonces, el sueño no se ha muerto?
Nereo: No. Nunca se va a morir
So the dream hasn’t died? I ask him. No, it will never die, he tells me.
[music cue]
Climate change is already displacing people within countries, but it’s also driving migrants and refugees across borders. That’s next time, on Displaced.
Companion story
Revisiting El Bosque, the “Success Story” of Climate Displacement
3 million people in Mexico could be displaced by climate change by 2050. Lessons learned from a rushed resettlement underscore what governments owe to climate-displaced communities—not only after homes wash away, but also long before.
